I’m not sure if you guys remember, but a couple of years back a theory surfaced online claiming that Avril Lavigne had killed herself in 2003 and was replaced with a double.
Featured Image VIA
And now, on the 15th anniversary of the release of her first hit single Complicated (God I’m old), the theory has resurfaced with some new “evidence” coming to the forefront.
Over the weekend a fan named ‘givincyass’ restarted the rumours in a Twitter thread that has since gone viral. In it, she claims that the singer took her own life following her grandfather’s death. It describes how the “death” happened in the peak of her career and so the record company hired a lookalike, Melissa Vandella, to impersonate her.
so she decided to hire a look alike to walk around LA for her and pose for the paparazzi (avril on the left, look alike on the right) pic.twitter.com/wNSrDVh09i
— festive yeehaw girl (@givenchyass) May 13, 2017
Apparently Vandella had already been hired previously to pose as the singer for paparazzi. This theory has done the rounds several times in the last few years and as such, there has been quite a build up of details to back it.
There has been analysis of differences between the two such as the shape of Avril’s nose and eyes.
Okay so I was looking at these and the corners of their eyes are shaped differently and now I'm geeking pic.twitter.com/ag2G37NsSt
— A (@ashlynnktigner) May 14, 2017
Theorists also claim that Avril’s second album Under My Skin is filled with subliminal messages and she even once posed for a photo with Melissa written on her hand:
In addition, they claim that Avril’s handwriting has changed over the years:
avrils old handwriting vs a latest tweet 🤔🤔🤔🤔 pic.twitter.com/1cwBbgSBfy
— the sweetest heart (@privatelaprip) May 14, 2017
Due to the resurfacing of this theory, when Avril recently posted a Happy Mother’s Day message on Twitter, fans replied with messages about Melissa:
Melissa it's okay. We're here for you.
— PAX Oshtralia (@DaveOshry) May 15, 2017
I’ve got to say, despite the many snippets of “evidence” provided by diehard fans, I’m not convinced. It’s clearly the same person and the facial “differences” are probably just down to camera angles. It seems a little farfetched that this could have happened with no solid evidence leaking at any point over the last 14 years. Sorry internet – it’s a good theory, but we’re not buying it.
For more celebrity death conspiracy theories, check out this one about Eminem.